| #9 | Averett | plays at | #7 | Guilford |
| #6 | Bridgewater VA | plays at | #2 | Hampden-Sydney |
| #8 | Gallaudet | plays at | #3 | Shenandoah |
| #7 | Guilford | plays | #9 | Averett |
| #2 | Hampden-Sydney | plays | #6 | Bridgewater VA |
| #5 | Roanoke | plays at | #4 | Washington & Lee |
| #3 | Shenandoah | plays | #8 | Gallaudet |
| #4 | Washington & Lee | plays | #5 | Roanoke |